MUSIC MENTORING MEMO

DAP/RECORDING ENGINEER'S QUARTERLY COPOST

DEFYING ALL ODDS

INTERVIEW OF JOHN MERMIS OF "SYMPATHY"  BY RON DUNBAR

Developing Artist Productions Motorcity Mentoring Memos are short articles on music business topics discussed on the RID Production Specialist Course.

     When I told Tom Gelardi about Long John Mermis, founder of Sympathy For The Record Industry record label, his reaction was You gotta be kidding.  Bucking all the big guys, he moves that many records?  He was impressed with a statistic of over 700 releases put out by one guy over 15 years (that averages a new release every 8 days or so).  He was impressed with the fact that the White Stripes had their breakout hit releases on the Sympathy label.
     We ran across John researching how the White Stripes broke out of the Motorcity a couple of years ago.  Our Developing Artist Production team is used to big record companies putting out hits.  John does it differently - he sells a lot of records (almost 2 million by our estimate) but relatively few of any one release.   It's a different way of being successful in the field and one that every independent producer should study.
    I couldn't resist the idea of Grammy Winning Ron Dunbar interviewing radical record entrepreneur
John Mermis.  Ron, who has helped run "hit-factory" labels questioning John, who runs a one-man show and averages a couple-three thousand units sold per release.
     - Bob Dennis, editor

Ron is in red.     John is in Navy Blue.
What happened was that your name came up in a discussion about the business, and someone mentioned this genius out in California - Sympathy for the record industry - what a great name! Someone needs to have some sympathy -- cuz things are messed up!  How long have you been in biz?     15 years!

What got you started?  Previous to this, I was a writer, wrote for local papers, co-edited a free newspaper called "Endless Party" so I went from being a writer and an intense record collector to one day putting out records myself.

Who was your influence?     Ralph records, who was the Resident's label, with an incredible style, and Stiff records, in England, my favorite label - the first ones to release people like Elvis Costello, the Damned, Nick Lowe (fg note - and DEVO) and I really admired that. And that's what Sympathy is. I didn't pattern after stuff, but they're the closest.

How do you hook up with bands?  Mostly from associations with other people. rarely through the mail. I have a criteria -- if I open a package, and there's a name I don't like - that's it. Or a picture i don't like - it's over. If there's a cd, and I actually put it on, that first track better be pretty damned amazing. I don't have time or tolerance for these things.  The most recent thing I have found is a band from buffalo NY called the "Bloody Hollies" - 3 piece band, really great, very excited about them

They sent you a package in the mail?     They sent me emails previously and started contact, I really liked the name, I'm a rather sarcastic guy -- I got the cd, checked it out, and they were great. I'm doing a record with them now.

I've been A/R and Exec Prod. If it doesn't get my ears right away....     Right. If the band doesn't know enough to put their best track first....

What do your groups need to do to support their records?  The most important thing a group can do is tour. People have to be able to see them. Great records are nice, but how is anyone supposed to know if they cant get out there and see the band. All the radio/interviews in the world are great, but without live shows....

They need to have things happening before you'd even deal with them then?     Most of the people I get involved with don't have a means of doing any substantial touring. if I sat around and waited for a band to have all the little boxes checked before I did anything with them, I don't think I'd have any records to put out. I put out what I like, I don't have anyone to discuss it with. I do what I want when I want to do it. No criteria other than my interests.

Is there any particular part of the country where you specifically look for talent?  No. matter of fact, when people zero in on something like that - ie, the whole detroit thing - i've had lots of bands from detroit. I think every city has it's own thing. Detroit got notoriety, but i don't think there's anything inherently special about the city. It's not unique, it's just gotten some focus. There are as many great and talented bands in every city in the US and every country around the world.    
One of the things I say about hit records -- there may be 100 hits on the chart, there were artists represented from across the country but not just one city...

Tell me about White Stripes.     I put out their first 3 albums. All they'd had out were 2 little 7" records on a little Detroit label.

How do you distribute/sell records?   I go through Mordam in Sacramento (so do the Dead Kennedys - FG) they sell directly to chains and to the mom/pops.

What about the internet?     Mordam handles net sales as well. it's very minor, but they're trying.

What do you think about the computer music thing?     I've never downloaded an mp3 - i don't listen to music on my computer. If other people want to share and trade my records, great! That may get someone to go out and pick up a record. I worry about the people who can't afford music - to pay $18-19 for a cd. My cds are priced to retail at $10.99 tops. That gives people incentive to buy something. when records are 17-18-19 bucks, I really have a soft spot for people who can't afford it. What? cause you can't afford it you cant have music?? They're not getting all the pretties - the artwork, the case, but if they want music, I say let them have it!

Tower etc has no problem with your list prices?      I have no control over what the stores ACTUALLy price them at, but mine invariably end up cheaper in stores like that because they're BUYING them cheaper. If you're looking at 2 cds, one is $19, one is $11, if you're debating over which to buy, chances are they're going to buy mine. I like to give people a good deal. At $17.99, someone is GOUGING the public -- being greedy motherf......s - if I could put together a cd for a couple bucks at MY level, then major label level - they're probably paying 50 cents. if they're paying fu.....g 50 cents, then why are they retailing for $18?

Greed. once a group has been successful in the indie area, should they move up to major level?     There are limitations to what someone like myself can do - working out of the house by myself - but it has a certain appeal. It's a big trade off. A band goes from indie to major and what they pick up is better distribution in some areas and what they lose is distribution in OTHER areas. the majors don't have ins with mom/pop stores.....you get something, you lose something.

Have you ever had a partner?     No, never had one. never had an employee. I guess the bottom line consideration is that I don't think i could afford help, and I'm completely stubborn. I don't want to discuss things. I work on impulse.

You're going to Boston?     To see 2 of my groups out there - people are getting excited about them - and I have this brand new band -- again, the Bloody Hollies.  Mr. Airplane man (in Boston) are my absolute favorite thing right now. It's blues based - the name comes from Howlin' Wolf. They do it really well. I'm not sure where to "place" it -- they're a really talented 2 piece band.

What is your release schedule?     For a while, it was one a week. 15 years, 700 releases.

Phenomenal! That shows commitment and dedication.     I've had to curtail that sort of enthusiasm. last year I destroyed several hundred thou worth of records that never sold. Distributors are sick of holding them.

Are you more conservative now?     I'm trying to be more discerning. I used to just do things with friends. I've paid for projects in the last 6 months that I've turned around and decided not to even put it out. I'm better off losing THAT money than paying for manufacturing and having it go nowhere. I'd rather lose X dollars than X times 2.... Competition is fierce. My distributor has around 30 labels. even within my own dist -- let's say they have 30 new records a month. They call up the stores, mention the records, and the stores say "who's that? I've never heard of that, I don't want those" I need a different MO for working with bands... 

What do you do when an act gets major label interest?     When something comes up, I call on the bands to be fair...the minute attorneys and managers get involved and wave fu....g carrots in front of their faces, they forget (FG Note: No shit...) and STILL scream that they're independent the whole time. They need that street credibility, but they don't really want it, they jump at the first opportunity to become some big major label act. Dont fu....g pretend that you're on this little subsidiary of this big fu....g monolith. you're STILL on that big label. You're working for the fu.....g MAN! - trying to have the best of both worlds...

I'm pretty reclusive. I don't have too much to do with other people. I'm really busy - don't have a lot of time - I do what I do, and if someone likes it, great. If not, oh well....I'm completely unwilling to change for anyone. I have no plans. I'm starting up a toy company right now called "Necessaries Toy Foundation" I'm working with established artists to create vinyl figures - I'm a big toy collector - just like I did with records, now I'm going to manufacture/create/distribute toys. I see that being very successful.

How old are you?   - 51.

You sound around 30! All those young bands keeping you young! This toy thing sounds great!       I'm certain its going to be a success. I'm working with a lot of great people on that. Sculptors/artists. The first batch should be out around Christmas. Not in toys r us.....there's another whole world. Just like there's a world outside of Virgin/Tower, it's toys r us versus the 2-3 little comic book shops in each town. That's what I'm aiming for.

You're impulsive - you need that freedom that having someone else around wouldn't provide. Well, thank you, this has been great

Check out the Sympathy For The Record Industry Site.

 

RETURN TO CURRENT ARTICLE INDEX

RETURN TO REQ HOME PAGE

RETURN TO DEVELOPING ARTIST PRODUCTIONS HOME PAGE

Copyright © 2003, by Robert Dennis, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Published in Recording Engineer's Quarterly and Alexander magazines with permission

USE OF THIS ARTICLE SUBJECT TO USER AGREEMENT